Author:  Sarah Penner

Year of Publication: May 9th, 2021

PLOT: 5/5

CHARACTERS: 5/5

WRITING: 5/5

CLIMAX: 4.6/5

ENTERTAINMENT: 5/5

BUY HERE

Plot:

Who wouldn’t want to solve a mystery that has been unsolved for a century, especially if it involved poisons that were used to kill unfaithful partners or husbands?

The first book by Sarah Penner has two plot lines, one in the past and one in the present, both of which are set in London. Caroline Parcewell, who was meant to be visiting London for her tenth anniversary, has just arrived. Caroline has escaped to London for some space after learning of her husband’s adultery just a few days earlier instead of taking in the beautiful sights. A little, glass vial Caroline discovers while “mudlarking” along the banks of the River Thames piques her curiosity and makes her remember her long-buried desire to pursue a career in history.

Nella is operating an apothecary in 1791, but it is only accessible to those who know exactly where to search. This secrecy is a result of the peculiar nature of Nella’s business, which involves giving poisons to women who want to get rid of problematic men in a time when such women have few escape routes. One day, Eliza Fanning, a 12-year-old, becomes Nella’s newest client. Eliza’s entrance and request will trigger a series of actions that will have profound effects on both Nella and Caroline.

What I really liked about the book?

I am astounded by Sarah Penner’s talent for developing these characters and the settings in which they exist. Any time a narrative takes place in London, I find it interesting, but the fact that this one takes place both in the present and the past makes it even more so. The concept of a lady assisting other women who find themselves in really difficult circumstances in a time when there were no other options fascinated me. Moreover, it was fantastic to see the current character conducting research on the previous ones. I adore the characters, as well as the harsh, realistic portrayals of both historical and contemporary London.

The main themes of this cleverly crafted novel are betrayal, grief, and retribution. The experiences told by several of the women were tragic. Women had no legal protection in the 1790s, I had to remind myself. Because of how effectively the primary characters were crafted, I found myself feeling deeply about them. I enjoyed how the reader was held in suspense and wondering what would happen to Nella and Eliza. Although there are two storylines in this book and three different narrators (Caroline, Nella, and Eliza), I had no trouble at all keeping the characters and timelines apart as I read.

Who should read this?

If you love reading unsolved mysteries of the past, then this one is definite yes for you.

Final Verdict

I loved this book and is one of the books that I will re-read in future. The Lost Apothecary is a highly well-researched, witty, entertaining, and original book. Highly recommended.